Analysis: Lower lease rate factors unnerve lessors | Analysis | Airfinance Journal

Analysis: Lower lease rate factors unnerve lessors

Export:

Lease rate factors are continuing to fall to what some believe are unhealthy levels, partly driven by fierce market competition and a desire for lessors to expand their Asia-Pacific businesses, market sources tell Airfinance Journal.

Lessor sources report seeing lease rate factors lower than 0.60% on various financings.

“The reality is that, yes, from time to time we see some very low lease rate factors. Even where the lease rents are not far off-market, there may have been a relatively high price paid for the aircraft asset which squeezes the return,” says one Singapore-based market source.

“Due to the amount of liquidity still in the market and strong competition among lessors, many airlines have no problem acquiring aircraft for decent rates, and those doing sale and leasebacks often benefit from premium pricing."

The person adds that some leasing companies – many of them based in Asia – appear to be under pressure to rapidly grow their portfolios – which inevitably leads to a willingness to sacrifice return for scale.

A Hong Kong-based leasing company source agrees, saying that the ball has moved squarely into the airline’s court in terms of negotiating power on lease deals.

The risk is that airlines will become “spoilt” by these cheap deals, the person says.

The person has heard that certain Chinese lessors will tell their airline customers: “Take whatever offer our competitor has made you and then take 5-10% off it – that’s what we’ll give you.”

While he doubts that airlines will lose money on these deals, they may experience problems at the end of the lease in terms of managing the residual value.

A Hong Kong-based banker agrees, saying: “Many people just assume they will have traded those assets before the expiry of the lease term, but I’m not sure you can entirely rely on those assumptions. The lessors will have to bear the burden of refinancing, remarketing and reconfiguration costs.”

The Hong Kong-based leasing company executive adds that he has seen eight-year lease tenors for widebody aircraft – something that was previously rather rare. He has also seen five- to eight-year leases for narrowbody aircraft.

An executive at a Chinese airline tells Airfinance Journal that for 2017/18 deliveries, he is seeing “pretty good pricing from local lessors”, which is better than what he was seeing last year.

“Especially for some local lessors which are very aggressive in pricing,” he says.

The Hong Kong-based banker says this problem is the result of “a lot of money chasing a couple of deals and that translates into high purchase price and low rentals – the famous ‘high-low deals’”.

“You really need to have a high leverage to make it work. As long as you have high loan-to-values (LTV) and cheap financing costs it works, but if you don’t meet those two conditions then leasing is not profitable at all. You just accept a lower return, a lower lease rental. They may take the view that they will resell those leases to somebody else down the road.

“They are just in an easy bubble market now so it’s ok as long as the money keeps going…but it’s not going to end in a pretty manner I guess.”

 Moody’s China downgrade

On the capital markets side of the business, market sources in China and those who do business there are observing the potential impact of Moody’s recent downgrade of China’s sovereign credit rating to A1 from Aa3 and change of outlook to stable from negative.

A lawyer based in China who works on aircraft finance transactions told Airfinance Journal that the impact on domestic deals will be limited, but that international transactions could be hit.

“Of course, there are many Chinese leasing companies who have set up and then the borrower will be an Irish special purpose vehicle that intends to borrow from banks in Europe, Singapore or Hong Kong. I guess in that kind of scenario, the funding cost and maybe some of the documentation will be impacted, but how that’s going to be is yet to be tested.”

The lawyer adds that the market will also need to see how the other rating agencies react to Moody’s downgrade.

 A Singapore-based law firm partner says the downgrade may make it more expensive for some Chinese businesses, including airlines and lessors, to borrow US dollars from non-Chinese banks and investors, and to issue debt successfully into international markets.

“This could drive them to borrow more from domestic Chinese banks – which might lead to a further downgrade in due course given this one has largely been driven, as I understand it, by concerns about the amount of domestic Chinese debt,” he says.

A Hong Kong-based banker says that the “logical impact” of the downgrade would be that upcoming bonds from the downgraded entities will come at a “slight premium”.

“The markets are not always entirely rational – far from it, but I would expect the upcoming bond issues to be a bit more expensive for those leasing companies. Then that would put the aircraft secured bank financings a bit more on the radar screen of those leasing companies that have been financing themselves through the bond markets,” he says.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Phasellus ultrices urna eu consequat pulvinar. Suspendisse malesuada scelerisque iaculis. Cras ut facilisis arcu, posuere efficitur nisi. Fusce dictum tortor ac nibh rhoncus auctor. Praesent nunc felis, elementum vel orci quis, sodales tincidunt nisi. Vestibulum vestibulum vel erat quis feugiat. Nam nec pulvinar velit. Nunc feugiat felis lacus, non condimentum urna interdum vitae. In laoreet hendrerit commodo. Sed diam arcu, tincidunt quis augue ac, venenatis consequat dui. Quisque maximus venenatis erat, sed malesuada quam malesuada at. Aenean non quam a ex vulputate laoreet. Praesent eget neque convallis, rhoncus lorem a, venenatis metus. Maecenas sed malesuada purus.

Integer vel neque vel odio tempor laoreet. Praesent vel malesuada dolor, sit amet aliquam augue. Cras magna tortor, ullamcorper nec tristique ac, accumsan quis metus. Integer in magna sit amet leo vulputate vulputate. In pretium quam libero. Cras a pulvinar arcu, et rutrum orci. Proin euismod, justo quis scelerisque porttitor, purus odio dignissim ex, eu rhoncus lorem dolor sit amet mi. Pellentesque in massa vel mauris tempus euismod. Aenean efficitur vestibulum arcu ut elementum. Nam rhoncus ligula vel enim iaculis, quis luctus dui interdum. Nulla erat mi, lacinia eu orci ut, hendrerit fermentum lorem. Sed non gravida quam. Pellentesque habitant morbi tristique senectus et netus et malesuada fames ac turpis egestas. Nulla bibendum erat odio, pharetra lobortis eros blandit a.

In et ultrices ante. Vestibulum consequat libero quis quam tempor, efficitur accumsan lacus sollicitudin. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Phasellus ac est lacus. Quisque in interdum urna, non pulvinar sem. Duis tristique tortor vel urna commodo tincidunt sit amet ut sem. In sapien turpis, porta vitae neque in, varius egestas erat.

Interdum et malesuada fames ac ante ipsum primis in faucibus. Donec quis est vel ante facilisis efficitur. Pellentesque tincidunt odio eget lacinia vestibulum. Aliquam erat volutpat. Ut ac ipsum non nisi convallis eleifend et ornare lectus. Pellentesque diam nulla, dapibus quis convallis sed, posuere at urna. Proin tincidunt tincidunt nibh, id molestie est. Integer iaculis, leo sit amet pulvinar pellentesque, tellus elit vehicula ipsum, eget vulputate dui tortor vitae sem. Proin rhoncus venenatis tellus, vitae blandit ipsum malesuada sed. Morbi gravida magna hendrerit faucibus imperdiet. Ut bibendum a massa at efficitur. Donec egestas urna urna, sit amet mattis erat fringilla sit amet. Integer scelerisque enim sed odio semper molestie. Sed tincidunt malesuada nulla a fringilla. Nullam suscipit, justo nec facilisis efficitur, arcu mauris finibus lorem, ut egestas mi purus nec neque. Nunc nec euismod est, ac egestas neque.

Vivamus sit amet pretium quam, vitae fringilla dolor. In nec ligula arcu. Fusce a tortor leo. Sed blandit leo quis turpis sodales, eget tincidunt tortor ultrices. Fusce scelerisque eros quis quam vestibulum tempus. Praesent sodales aliquam nibh vel fermentum. Quisque vel diam sit amet sem convallis interdum. Proin ac velit molestie, malesuada tellus vitae, tempus est. Sed facilisis ut enim ac pretium. Mauris scelerisque fermentum risus, nec ultricies enim finibus vel. Aenean sem enim, dictum mollis aliquet nec, consequat nec nisl. Duis aliquam a lectus vitae ornare.


Regional Snapshot

Related Data

Transaction Snapshot
Air Company | Bond issue | 01-24 | $1.5bn
Financial Close:
11/02/2024
SPV:
Some Aviation Trust
Value:
$1,500.00m USD
Full Details